Living in Long Island means your roofs need to be prepared for all the seasons and their extremes, from snowy winters to harsh fall storms. For this reason, while some property updates may be elective, roof replacement and repairs are not a choice.
The right roofing material is crucial for the integrity and aesthetics of your home. Not only does it help increase the resale value of the property, but it also impacts the overall longevity of the roof.
Roofing contractors on Long Island offer a wide variety of roof types for you to choose from. But as one of the most expensive projects your home would take on, homeowners need to know what sets each roof apart. In this comparative analysis, we have compiled details on roofing shingles, metal roofing, and tile roofing to help you make an informed decision.
Let’s take a look.
Types of Roofing in Long Island
Picking the right roofing materials for your roof can be overwhelming. While trusted roofing contractors in Long Island will typically guide you on which material—metal roofing, tile roofing, or roofing shingles—to choose, you must also be aware of the differences.
Shingle Roofing in Long Island
Best Fit For:
- First-time homeowners
- People who need to replace their roof on a tight budget
- DIY-savvy people who don’t mind doing small repairs themselves
- Homes in inland areas or with moderate storm exposure
Whether you’ve just moved here and are giving your home a fresh new look or have lived here a while and need to do some post-storm damage fixing, you may have heard of shingle roofing while you’re around. Shingle roofing—or, more precisely, asphalt shingle roofing is the go-to roofing material around Long Island and all over the US.
These shingles are made from a fiberglass base, which gives them strength, and then they’re coated in asphalt to waterproof them. Finally, mineral granules are added on top for texture, protection from UV rays, and that classic speckled look you’ve seen on most neighborhood rooftops.
The Main Types of Asphalt Shingles:
- 3-Tab Shingles: Flat and uniform-looking with a clean, simple style.
- Architectural (Dimensional) Shingles: Thicker, with a layered texture that mimics wood shake or slate.
- Luxury (Designer) Shingles: Heaviest and thickest of the lot. Designed to look like slate or cedar, without the high price tag.
How Does Shingle Roofing Hold Up in Long Island’s Climate?
Roofing contractors in Long Island would normally pick architectural asphalt shingles for your roofing. The reason for this is that they have better wind resistance, up to 130 mph. However, if you live closer to the South Shore, you might need to get more frequent maintenance, especially during the occasional surprise hail. Plus, the salty air and heavy winds can gradually wear down those granules faster than in landlocked towns. So, don’t expect them to last forever, and be mindful if your house is in a storm-heavy zone like Freeport, Patchogue, or Montauk.
Lifespan & Maintenance
The type you choose, how far from the coast you are, and the care you give to the roof all matter to make it last longer. Typically, asphalt shingle roofing can last you up to 15 to 20 years. However, if you are using installations from a top-tier roofing contractor in Long Island, they might push 25 years.
While shingles don’t age gracefully—faded color, curling edges, granule loss, and the occasional missing tab after a storm—they are fast and flexible with repairs. So, in case a problem happens, repairs are typically quick, easy, and cheap. This is a huge plus compared to more complicated roofing systems.
One of the perks of asphalt shingles is low maintenance. You won’t need to fuss over them constantly, and if a storm damages a few pieces, you can usually just swap out the affected shingles without replacing the whole roof. Plus, it’s always best to get an inspection done by a roofing contractor in Long Island after a storm to look for any signs of trouble.
Quick Pros & Cons Recap
Pros:
- The most affordable roofing option upfront
- Easy and fast to install
- Massive local installer availability
- Simple spot repairs
- Lightweight and fits most home structures easily
Cons:
- Shorter lifespan depending on the type
- Can trap summer heat
- Not very energy efficient
- Generally not recyclable, adding to landfill waste
Also Read: How Much Does Roof Repair Cost in 2025?
Metal Roofing in Long Island
Best Fit For:
- Homeowners planning to stay long-term
- Coastal or storm-prone neighborhoods
- People who want to cut their energy bills
- Eco-conscious renovators
If you’ve been living in your home for as long as you can remember, and your roof is barely hanging on after all those hurricanes, you might be thinking, “What’s a roof that can really go the distance?” Well, metal roofing!
Metal roofing doesn’t just offer you that sleek, modern style but also serious durability, energy efficiency, and intense peace of mind. A metal roof is made from steel, aluminum, or copper panels that are then insulated and designed to interlock tightly to keep out the elements.
The Main Types of Metal Roofing
- Standing Seam Panels: Clean vertical lines, seamless edges. Fasteners are hidden, which adds to the sleek look.
- Corrugated Metal Panels: A bit more industrial-looking, but very strong and affordable.
- Metal Shingles: Looks like traditional asphalt or slate shingles but is made from coated metal.
How Does Metal Roofing Hold Up in the Long Island Climate?
In short: like a champ! Long Island’s weather makes sure to throw all curveballs at your roof, and metal roofing is built for that sort of thing. If you’re in areas close to Babylon, Long Beach, or Montauk, you’d be glad to know that metal roofing can handle wind speeds up to 140 mph. And with the amount of moisture and humidity around coastal areas, aluminum roofs are perfect, as they don’t rust. Also worth noting? Metal doesn’t rot, crack, or warp. No mold, no pests, no moisture buildup. You don’t have to worry about squirrels chewing their way in or shingles curling up after a humid summer.
Lifespan & Maintenance
The first reason why people love metal roofing is for its durability and longevity. Once you get it installed by a trusted roofing contractor in Long Island, it can last you for 40 to 70 years. If you go for the copper or zinc options, the lifespan can go up to 100 years, or even beyond. But this type of lifespan comes with a cost (which we will discuss in the next section). However, once it’s installed, you won’t need to re-roof again. And if this will be your home for the long haul, then this roof is here to stay for the next generation—and maybe more.
Seems too good to be true? Well, we have more to add! Metal roofing is also hands-off! This means you don’t have to worry about replacing patches or curling corners every once in a while. All you need to check for occasionally are loose fasteners, debris, and worn coatings and finishes. So, if you want a “get it done and forget it” kind of roof, this is as close as it gets.
Quick Pros & Cons Recap
Pros:
- Long lifespan (40- 70+ years)
- Handles Long Island storms like a pro
- Aluminum means no rust, ideal for salty coastal air
- Energy-efficient and UV-reflective
- Modern and versatile looks
- Fire-, mold-, and pest-resistant
- Fully recyclable and eco-conscious
Cons:
- Expensive upfront cost
- Requires skilled, experienced installers
- Some cheaper metal roofs may show subtle waviness in flat areas, aka “oil canning”
Tile Roofing in Long Island
Best Fit For:
- Long-term thinkers
- Eco-conscious individuals
- Anyone seeking a set-it-and-forget-it roofing solution
- Those willing to invest more upfront for lasting value
If you’re craving something that has serious character, curb appeal, and staying power, tile roofing might just be the one for you. Tiles that are used in roofing are made of natural materials like concrete, slate, or clay. This gives them that evergreen and timeless look. Tile roofing is mostly used on custom high-end homes and has been used for centuries due to its longevity when taken care of.
The Main Type of Tile Roofing
- Clay Tile: Traditional terracotta look; super durable and eco-friendly.
- Concrete Tile: Slightly more affordable than clay, with added strength and versatility.
- Slate Tile: The most premium (and heavy) option; made from natural stone with a refined, textured finish.
How Does Tile Roofing Hold Up in Long Island’s Climate?
Typically, tile roofing excels in hot, dry climates as it reflects sunlight and helps regulate indoor temperatures. So, it might not be the first idea a roofing contractor in Long Island would run through your mind. However, it is perfect for homeowners who value aesthetics and live in areas with strong sun exposure, as they can benefit from the energy efficiency of tile roofing. So, it is not traditionally associated with the Northeast, but it is still a great choice.
Lifespan & Maintenance
When we talk about the lifespan of tile roofing, there are a few things you need to consider. First of all, tile roofs require expert installation by roofing contractors in Long Island. Before you commit, you would need to get a professional inspection to check the structural reinforcement of your home. If it’s a new build, then it should be designed with tile in mind. Once it is properly installed, it can last for 100 years and beyond. It’s also wind-, fire-, and pest-resistant.
When it comes to maintenance, you don’t have to worry about it since, come what may, they will remain unfazed. However, if they do break, it’s easier to replace individual tiles without ripping off the whole roof. If you live near water or have a shaded roof, keep gutters clean and check for any algae growth, and that’s about it.
Quick Pros & Cons Recap
Pros:
- Very long-lasting (50- 100+ years)
- Gorgeous, high-end look
- Fire-, UV-, and pest-resistant
- Energy-efficient
- Eco-conscious option
Cons:
- Heavy and may require structural upgrades
- Expensive upfront
- Fragile underfoot
- Not DIY-friendly
- Needs occasional cleaning to avoid moss/algae buildup.
What to Consider Before Starting Your Roofing Project in Long Island
Choosing the right roof is a big decision, and it’s not something you want to rush through. Take your time and really think about how your choices will impact your home now and in the future. Don’t be afraid to ask your roofing contractor in Long Island any questions. The following are some things you would need to factor in, typically:
City Codes and Regulations
Local regulations are often very specific about what kind of roofing materials you can use in certain areas. They put these rules in place due to wind resistance, fire safety, and also sometimes the general aesthetic of the area. So, before you ask your roofing contractor in Long Island if they can install a certain type of roof, ask if the local building department allows it.
Budget
You might have picked your dream material, but you also need to balance your budget. Not only do you need to factor in the cost of the materials, but also labor and reinforcement costs. Steep roofs, for example, might need extra structural support, which can drive the price up. It’s always good to get a few quotes from roofing contractors in Long Island and be clear about the total price.
Roof Pitch
Roof installations are not just about aesthetics but also functionality. Steep slopes need extra secure options to be able to withstand the pressure. Plus, steep roofs are also more labor-intensive and require added protection to install. On the other hand, while a low-pitch roof would be easier to install, it also means you’d have fewer options to work with.
Local Availability
You might be tempted by a rare material that might need to be imported. However, they also require higher costs because of specialized labor and shipping. So, make sure what you like is easy to get your hands on, is within your budget, and that the local roofing contractors in Long Island have the expertise to work with it.
Climate
As discussed earlier, climate is key. You don’t want one that isn’t weather-resistant, especially in an area like Long Island. For example, if you live in an area prone to heavy snowfall, you’ll want a material that won’t get weighed down too easily. In warmer areas, heat resistance could be a priority, as you don’t want your roof absorbing too much heat and cranking up your cooling costs in the summer. So think about what kind of weather your roof will need to handle year-round.
Weight
You really need to think about the weight of the roofing material and if the structural integrity of your home can handle the added weight. If it’s an older home, you can not skip the structural inspection to ensure your roof stays safe and secure after installation. If you like a gorgeous option, but it requires underlying support from the structure, you may need to rethink your plan and even budget.
Aesthetic
Obviously, you’d want a roof that you actually like. Sure, the roof is there to do its job, but you want to take one look at it and think: wow, I’m glad I chose this. The color, texture, and shape of your roofing material can really change your home’s curb appeal. Whether your aesthetic is more classy or unique, make sure your choice pulls the entire look together.
Hire the Best Roofing Contractor in Long Island: Delta Roofing Long Island
When it comes to building a home, roofs are not a place you’d want to skimp on. Roofing a house is something you, as a homeowner, will prefer to do once. If all goes well, hopefully, the job will outlast your time in the home.
Tile roofing, shingle roofing, and metal roofing—the options for roofing solutions don’t end here. At Delta Roofing Long Island, with our wealth of experience and a myriad of options, we can help you pick the roof that you’ve always dreamt of, since only a qualified roofer has the right set of skills you need to pick the right roof for your dwelling.
Looking for valuable insights and a beautiful job done on your roof? Contact us today.
